Oh Mr. Ornish

food

Scientific American recently released an article titled Why Almost Everything Dean Ornish Says about Nutrition Is Wrong.  Dean Ornish is well known for his almost 4 decades of advocating for a low-fat, carb-heavy, vegetarian diet.

This article will come as no surprise to most herbalists.  It contains a good overview of some of the recent research that debunks Ornish’s proposals.

So there’s little evidence to suggest that we need to avoid protein and fat. But what about the claims Ornish makes about the success of his own diet—do they hold up to scrutiny? Not exactly.

Discuss this post on our discussion forums.

Jiddu Krishnamurti on Happiness

jiddu_krishnamurti_happiness

We may move from one refinement to another, from one subtlety to another, from one enjoyment to another; but at the center of it all, there is the ‘me’, the ‘me’ that is enjoying, that wants more happiness, the ‘me’ that searches, looks for, longs for happiness, the ‘me’ that struggles, the ‘me’ that becomes more and more refined, but never likes to come to an end. It is only when the ‘me’ in all subtle forms comes to an end that there is a state of bliss which cannot be sought after, an ecstasy, a real joy without pain, without corruption.

When the mind goes beyond the thought of the ‘me’, the experiencer, the observer, the thinker, then there is a possibility of a happiness that is incorruptible. That happiness cannot be permanent, in the sense in which we use that word. But, our mind is seeking permanent happiness, something that will last, that will continue. That very desire for continuity is corruption.

If we can understand the process of life without condemning, without saying it is right or wrong, then, I think, there comes a creative happiness which is not ‘yours’ or ‘mine’. That creative happiness is like sunshine. If you want to keep the sunshine to yourself, it is no longer the clear, warm life-giving sun. Similarly, if you want happiness because you are suffering, or because you have lost somebody, or because you have not been successful, then that is merely a reaction. But when the mind can go beyond, then there is a happiness that is not of the mind.

Jiddu Krishnamurti

Discuss this post on our discussion forums.

Adaptogens Questioned

ginseng

Very simply, adaptogens are nontoxic, produce a nonspecific defensive response to stress and have a normalizing influence on the body. As defined, adaptogens constitute a new class of natural, homeostatic metabolic regulator. — David Winston and Steven Maimes

Paul Bergner has a very interesting slide presentation titled the Dark Side of Adaptogens.  Unfortunately this paper does not appear to be available online anymore, but it still available as part of the Fatigue: Pathophysiology, Natural Therapeutics, and Adaptogens course.

The subtitle to this talk on the Dark Side of Adaptogens is “How the indiscriminate use of tonic herbs can promote burnout and deep injury to the endocrine system”.

One of the parts I found most interesting about this talk was questioning the need for an adaptogenic approach when tonic herbs already have a well defined role within the traditional systems of health.  Tonic herbs are used in very careful ways at the appropriate times with the appropriate indications.  The modern usage of adaptogens as a silver bullet, in isolation, and without a holistic consideration or the backing of a well assessed health restoration plan can do more harm than good.

Tonifying herbs strengthen the processes of the body, including the pathogenic processes. Thus tonifying herbs should not be prescribed in cases where there are still signs of an exterior disorder. If they are, the exterior disorder will linger on. — Bensky and Gamble (Chinese Materia Medica)

We have a thread started on our discussion forums to discuss adaptogens.

Low-Carb Diet for Athletes

runner

 

An article in the British Journal of Sports Medicine titled Low-carbohydrate diets for athletes: what evidence? reviews the studies done on the performance effects of low-carbohydrate diets. There are very few of such studies and most are not well designed.

What we particularly enjoyed about this paper was its questioning of the conventional wisdom that athletes need to consume carbohydrates. It also raised questions such as the adverse effects of carbohydrate consumption as well as the often un-thought about benefits of a low-carb diet (prevents insulin resistance, effect on the immune system, weight control, and so forth).

Discuss this post on our forums.

Metabolic Syndrome

We have a thread on our forum titled Metabolic Syndrome / Syndrome X / Insulin Resistance.  Thankfully several esteemed herbalist have written about this common condition.  An estimated 86 million American adults have prediabetes.  Only a partial number of those with insulin resistance will go on to develop diabetes but insulin resistance itself will cause a host of other problems.

Paul Bergner, from his article on Syndrome X, provides us the salient warning that treatment must be carried out with discipline:

The treatment has three legs, all of which must be done simultaneously:

-Supplement the nutritional factors whose deficiencies lead to insulin resistance.

-Enagage in a minimum of 15-20 minutes of resistance-type exercise most days.

-Eat a low carbohydrate diet.

Cayenne Pepper Roundup

cayenne

We started a forum post on Cayenne that includes links to excellent articles by Todd Caldecott and Michael Tierra as well as other sources.

Not a tonic or immunostimulant, it [cayenne] acts as a peripheral vasodilator, increasing blood supply to the skin and mucosa. It is NOT appropriate for active inflammation. — Michael Moore (Herbal Medical Contradictions)